So, the other day, I was all set to whip up this killer stew recipe that my grandma used to make. It’s got this unique flavor that just takes me back to being a kid. The secret ingredient? Caraway seeds. They’re not something I usually keep in my pantry, but I figured, “Hey, I’ll just grab some from the store.”
Well, guess what? The store was completely out of caraway seeds! Can you believe it? I stood there in the spice aisle, staring at the empty spot where the caraway seeds should have been, feeling totally defeated. I mean, this stew just isn’t the same without them. But I wasn’t about to give up that easily.
I started racking my brain, trying to think of what else I could use. I knew caraway seeds had this kind of, like, licorice-y, peppery taste. So I needed something that could mimic that. I remembered seeing a bunch of different seeds and spices on the shelves, and I started grabbing anything that seemed remotely close.

First up, fennel seeds. I’d heard they had a similar flavor to caraway, so I grabbed a jar of those. They definitely smelled licorice-like, so I had high hopes. I also picked up some anise seeds because, well, they’re in the same flavor family, right? I was just throwing stuff in my basket at this point, desperate for a solution.
Back home, I decided to do a little taste test. I toasted some of the fennel seeds and some of the anise seeds separately in a dry pan to release their flavors. I even found a tiny bit of old caraway seeds hiding in the back of my cupboard for comparison. After tasting all three, I realized the fennel seeds were the closest match. They had that same warm, licorice-y flavor, just a bit sweeter. The anise seeds were okay, but they were a little too strong on the licorice and not much else.
My Experiment Results
- Fennel Seeds: These were the winner. Toasted them lightly, and they worked like a charm in the stew.
- Anise Seeds: Too overpowering for my taste. Might work if you really, really love licorice, but not for me.
In the end, I used the toasted fennel seeds in my stew, and you know what? It turned out pretty darn good! It wasn’t exactly the same as my grandma’s, but it was close enough. And honestly, it was kind of fun experimenting and figuring out a substitute. So, if you ever find yourself in a caraway seed crisis, don’t panic! Just grab some fennel seeds, toast them up, and you’re good to go.
And this is my little story of substituting caraway seed with my grandma’s recipe, hope this experience could help you!
Post Comment