Substitute Marshmallows for Marshmallow Cream: Easy DIY Guide

Substitute Marshmallows for Marshmallow Cream: Easy DIY Guide
Substitute Marshmallows for Marshmallow Cream: Easy DIY Guide

Alright, listen up, y’all. We’re gonna talk about somethin’ sweet today – substitutin’ marshmallows for marshmallow cream. Now, I ain’t no fancy baker, but I know my way around the kitchen, and sometimes you just gotta make do with what ya got. So, let’s get down to brass tacks.

First off, can you even do it? Can you swap out that gooey marshmallow cream for regular ol’ marshmallows? Well, the short answer is, yeah, most of the time you can. But it ain’t always a straight swap, ya hear? It’s like tryin’ to put a square peg in a round hole – sometimes it works, sometimes it don’t.

  • When it Works: If you’re makin’ somethin’ that gets melted down anyway, like a gooey rice crispy treat or some kinda frosting, then yeah, marshmallows will do just fine. You just gotta melt ’em down good and proper. We’ll talk more about that later.
  • When it Don’t: Now, if you’re tryin’ to stuff marshmallows into somethin’ that needs that creamy texture right away, like a whoopie pie fillin’, well, that’s where it gets tricky. You can’t just shove a marshmallow in there and expect it to be the same. It’ll be chunky, not smooth.

So, how do ya do it? How do you turn those fluffy little marshmallows into somethin’ like that store-bought cream stuff? It ain’t rocket science, I tell ya.

Substitute Marshmallows for Marshmallow Cream: Easy DIY Guide

Here’s the easiest way I know:

You take a bunch of marshmallows, the big ones are best, and you throw ’em in a pot. Not just any pot, mind you. You need a double boiler, or somethin’ like it. That’s one pot of water simmering on the stove with a heat-safe bowl on top that fits right in. Don’t want to burn your sweets now. Now, if you don’t have one of them fancy double boilers, you can just put a bowl over a pot of simmerin’ water. Just make sure the bowl don’t touch the water. Add a little bit of corn syrup – that stuff makes it all smooth and shiny. Then, you just stir and stir and stir until it all melts down into a nice, gooey mess. It’s like magic but for the kitchen.

How many marshmallows you need depends on what you’re makin’. But I’d say, a good rule of thumb is, for every cup of that cream stuff you need, use about sixteen big marshmallows or a whole mess of the little ones. Maybe like a hundred and sixty of the small ones. And don’t forget that corn syrup – about two teaspoons or so. That’s my rule of thumb and its never failed me. You can eyeball it, really. It ain’t gotta be perfect.

Now, what if you don’t have corn syrup? Well, you can try a little bit of water, or maybe even some milk. But it might not be exactly the same. Corn syrup’s the best, in my opinion. It just makes it all nice and smooth, ya know?

And what about makin’ your own marshmallow cream from scratch? Can you do that? Sure, you can. But it’s a whole lot more work. You need egg whites, and corn syrup, and powdered sugar, and vanilla. And you gotta whip it all up just right. It’s a pain in the neck, if you ask me. I’d rather just melt down some marshmallows. It’s faster and easier.

So, let’s talk about taste. What’s the difference between marshmallow cream and just plain marshmallows? Well, the cream’s a bit sweeter, I think. And it’s definitely smoother. Marshmallows are a bit fluffier. But once you melt ’em down, they’re pretty darn close. Close enough for most folks, anyway. Unless you’re one of them fancy-pants chefs, then I suppose you might notice the difference. But for everyday cookin’, it don’t matter much. It’s all sweet and gooey and good.

Think about it like this: if you’re makin’ a hot chocolate, you don’t need no fancy cream, right? You just throw in some marshmallows, and they melt down all nice and gooey. Same thing with rice crispy treats, or frosting, or anythin’ else that needs somethin’ sweet and melted. Marshmallows work just fine.

But if you’re makin’ somethin’ fancy, like a layer cake or a pie, well, then you might want to use the real deal cream stuff. Or, you can try meltin’ down those marshmallows extra careful, and maybe addin’ a little bit more corn syrup to make it extra smooth. It’s all about experimenting. Don’t be scared to try new things in the kitchen.

Substitute Marshmallows for Marshmallow Cream: Easy DIY Guide

Now, I ain’t no expert, but I’ve been cookin’ for a long time. And I’ve learned a few things along the way. And one thing I know is that you can usually find a way to make do with what you got. So, if you ain’t got no marshmallow cream, don’t sweat it. Just grab a bag of marshmallows and get to meltin’. It’ll be just fine. Trust me on this one.

And that’s all there is to it. Substitutin’ marshmallows for marshmallow cream ain’t hard. Just takes a little bit of know-how and a whole lot of common sense. Now get in that kitchen and start cookin’!

Post Comment